Publications des agents du Cirad

Cirad

Disseminating price information through mobile phone: are Malagasy farmers ready for it?

David-Benz H., Andriandralambo N., Rahelizatovo N.. 2017. In : Conference proceedings of 2017 EFITA WCCA congress: European conference dedicated to the future use of ICT in the agri-food sector, bioresource and biomass sector. Montpellier : IRSTEA, p. 85-86. European Federation for Information in Agriculture, Food and Environment (EFITA 2017), 2017-07-02/2017-07-06, Montpellier (France).

The efficiency of agricultural markets in developing countries is constrained by the asymmetry of information among actors along the value chains, with farmers being at the weakest position (Fafchamps & Gabre-Madhin 2006). Farmers' access to market information would then improve their spatial and temporal arbitration capacity as well as their market power (David-Benz et al. 2012; Shepherd 1997). This is one of the objectives of the Market Information Systems (MIS), which were first promoted in the developing countries in the 1980s and 1990s. From early 2000s, a second generation of MIS emerged, involving information and communication technologies (ICT) and particularly mobile phone (Galtier et al., 2014). ICT is identified as a major lever for development in Africa (Loukou 2013; World Bank 2012). However, effective use of MIS by farmers in developing countries remains marginal (Galtier et al., 2014), despite the high penetration of mobile phone in rural areas. What are the constraints linked to farmers' adoption of the MIS? According to Galtier et al. (2014), the failure of the second generation of MIS to meet farmers' needs is largely due to (i) the lack of close monitoring and evaluation of the very fast progress in the innovations, and (ii) the risk of exclusion with regards to smallholders' access to ICTs. Compliance with the needs of the target population, as well as their capacity to use SMS-based devises, within fast changing contexts, have been highlighted as one of the conditions for the MIS effectiveness (Burrell & Oreglia 2015, Garuku, Winters & Stepman 2009; Shepherd 1997). This communication is addressing these assumptions. Based on rapid surveys of recipients at the initial steps of the development of new dissemination tools, we analyze the adequacy of the use of SMS to disseminate information to smallholder farmers. In Madagascar, the development of the MIS started in 2005 with the creation of the Rice Observatory (OdR) and the Vegetable Economic Information System (Siel). Both systems recently started to introduce the use of mobile phone in the collection and dissemination of market information: in 2014 for the OdR and in 2016 for the Siel. During an initial test phase, a selection of prices was sent weekly via SMS to a sample of producers. Such test was carried out with farmers involved in different crops and at different locations: rice farmers producing in one area close to the capital city and in another landlocked area in the North of the country, and vegetable farmers on the outskirts of Antananarivo. After a few months of weekly diffusion of SMS, feedbacks from the target producers were collected via rapid field surveys or using phone calls, in order to have an early appraisal of the new dissemination methods and be able to rapidly adjust them. The results show that farmers' sources of information about market situation are diverse. Direct communication with relatives or buyers remains the major means to access information. Mobile phone penetration is uneven across the surveyed areas (mobile phone ownership ranges from 46% of the households in the most landlocked area to 75% of those in the rice-growing area close to the capital city); and only about 10% of producers use their mobile phone to make inquiries about product prices or to contact a buyer before selling . Radio is mostly used for entertainment and agriculture related programs are rare. The more the producers are involved in market transactions (ie. trading large quantities and selling beyond farm-gate), the better-off they are, the more they are willing to receive detailed and personalized information (via SMS or voice systems) and the more they are willing to pay for such information. The level of understanding the meaning of the messages differs according to the context: for rice farmers, those having a good understanding are about 39% in the landlocked area, and 75% in the vicinity of the capital city; as for vegetable production, it acc...

Documents associés

Communication de congrès

Agents Cirad, auteurs de cette publication :