Beyond tradition and modernity: the resilience of a farmer managed irrigation system in transition to drip irrigation
Van der Kooij S., Kuper M., Venot J.P., Zwarteveen M.. 2014. In : Resilience and development: mobilising for transformation. Villeurbanne : Centre pour la Communication Scientifique Directe, p. 38-38. Resilience Alliance 2014, 2014-05-04/2014-05-08, Montpellier (France).
Farmer managed irrigation schemes generally combine a relatively basic irrigation infrastructure with elaborate management rules. Analyses often explain the resilience and durability of farmer managed irrigation systetms by looking for commonalities and regularities across space in both infrastructure and institutions. Such analyses create the suggestion that they change little over time and indeed belong to a rather rigid world of customs and traditions, informing an analysis along a modern-tradition evolutionary binary. Moroccan irrigation policies likewise associate farmer managed irrigation systems with tradition, and quality them as too inflexible and complex to effectively accomodate the new, modern and rational drip irrigation systems that it is promoting as part of its agricultural modernization plans. In this paper, we offer a different approach to farmer managed irrigation systems, locating their resilience instead in the ability of the system to flexibly adapt to changes in bio-physical and socio-economic contexts, including those provoked by state interventions. We base this argument on an in-depth historical analysis of a surface irrigated farmer managed irrigation system in Morocco. The water users organisation of the Seguia Khrichfa has shown, and continues to show, a high level of flexibility and adaptability in changing watter allocation rules and practices to better meet changing needs of water users. It has creatively reacted to changing discharges, cropping patterns and policies by changing the water turn, the main d' eau or the technology in use. Currently, and defying its categorization as traditional, the users of thet Seguia Khrichfa are planning a transition from surface irrigation to drip irrigation. 'Traditional' irrigation institutions do not necessarily hinder drip irrigation use. Water rights and irrigation practices in the farmer managed irrigation system do indeed influence farmer's practices with drip irrigation but at the same time
Documents associés
Communication de congrès
Agents Cirad, auteurs de cette publication :
- Kuper Marcel — Es / UMR G-EAU